After a season filled with dramatic highs and lows, even The Bachelor himself can still manage to be surprised.
The March 14 Women Tell All special—in which all of the contestants from Zach Shallcross‘ season reunited to air their dirty laundry—featured one shocking moment after another. (For all the bombshells, click here.)
However, in an exclusive interview with E! News, Zach revealed one particular revelation stood head and shoulders above the rest.
“I was surprised by Kat‘s allegation of Anastasia having a boyfriend the whole time,” Zach admitted. “That was a little shocking.”
During the episode, Kat claimed she had “receipts” that Anastasia had a secret partner throughout filming, which Anastasia denied.
“I don’t know if it’s true or not,” Zach continued. “But that got me. That was a curveball.”
In addition to addressing the more scandalous parts of the season, Women Tell All also allowed Zach to come face-to-face with the women for the first time since production.